Academic Jobs Wiki
No edit summary
 
(35 intermediate revisions by 17 users not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
   
 
'''GOOD LUCK AHA INTERVIEWEES!!!'''
 
'''GOOD LUCK AHA INTERVIEWEES!!!'''
 
===Latin American History===
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37812 Adelphi University]
 
 
::any news?
 
 
   
   
   
  +
=== Latin American History ===
   
  +
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37812 Adelphi University]
   
  +
::any news?
 
::12/07 -- I was contacted a couple of days ago about scheduling an AHA interview
 
::12/07 -- I was contacted a couple of days ago about scheduling an AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10: email rejection letter received
 
::12/10: email rejection letter received
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/09: rejection letter received via email
 
::12/09: rejection letter received via email
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/19: rejection letter by email
 
::12/19: rejection letter by email
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/8: Campus visit scheduled
 
::1/8: Campus visit scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/21; Rejection email received
 
::1/21; Rejection email received
  +
::
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37903 Arizona State University, West Campus]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37903 Arizona State University, West Campus]
   
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::(12/4) Their deadline isn't until 12/12 (which is annoying considering they're going to the AHA).
 
::(12/4) Their deadline isn't until 12/12 (which is annoying considering they're going to the AHA).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::(12/16) Apparently this search is still progressing, although ASU Main's searches were canceled--a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West emailed my advisor--apparently the final decision for interviewees will be made on Wed. and forwarded to the dean--I don't know the timeline from there
 
::(12/16) Apparently this search is still progressing, although ASU Main's searches were canceled--a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West emailed my advisor--apparently the final decision for interviewees will be made on Wed. and forwarded to the dean--I don't know the timeline from there
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/18 Interview scheduled.
 
::12/18 Interview scheduled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/12 Invited for on-campus interview
 
::1/12 Invited for on-campus interview
  +
::
  +
::3/9 Offer made
  +
::3/17 Offer accepted
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37161 Central Michigan University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37161 Central Michigan University]
   
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/15-- no news.
 
::12/15-- no news.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone know who is the SC? There was not one at the time of the application.
 
::Anyone know who is the SC? There was not one at the time of the application.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/17 AHA interview scheduled.
 
::12/17 AHA interview scheduled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::01/23 Received phone call for on-campus interview. (X2)
 
::01/23 Received phone call for on-campus interview. (X2)
  +
::3/14 Offer accepted by Jonathan Truitt (identified in letter from SC)
 
 
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37295 Centre College]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37295 Centre College]
   
 
::12/3 scheduled interview at AHA today
 
::12/3 scheduled interview at AHA today
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/7 Campus visit scheduled
 
::1/7 Campus visit scheduled
  +
::Candidate accepted offer
 
 
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36832 Colgate University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36832 Colgate University]
   
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::(12/4) I received the AA/EOE form a couple of weeks ago, but nothing other than that
 
::(12/4) I received the AA/EOE form a couple of weeks ago, but nothing other than that
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/6 AHA interview scheduled (x3)
 
::12/6 AHA interview scheduled (x3)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Does the (x3) mean three people have scheduled interviews? Thanks, in advance, for the clarification! Yes.
 
::Does the (x3) mean three people have scheduled interviews? Thanks, in advance, for the clarification! Yes.
  +
: Does any one know what is happening with Colgate have they sent all of their interview/rejection letters yet (12/20/08)?
 
  +
: No, and I have emailed to ask. No communication of any sort. That is real ''classy''
 
  +
:Campus interview scheduled
 
  +
:4/20 got a letter today saying that no one was hired. And just the other day I noticed that they posted a VAP opening. Any idea what's going on?
 
  +
4/27 They are hiring for a one-year position, and most likely doing the search again next year.
 
 
:Does any one know what is happening with Colgate have they sent all of their interview/rejection letters yet (12/20/08)?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::No, and I have emailed to ask. No communication of any sort. That is real ''classy''
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::campus interview scheduled
 
 
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36598 Drury University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36598 Drury University]
   
Line 187: Line 61:
   
 
::12/14 from the SC, search is "on hold"
 
::12/14 from the SC, search is "on hold"
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/15 Any indication why or what the timeline is?
 
::12/15 Any indication why or what the timeline is?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::12/16 Few details provided by the SC, but the impression I got was that it is related to financial matters (big surprise).
 
:::12/16 Few details provided by the SC, but the impression I got was that it is related to financial matters (big surprise).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/24: Just got the official letter stating the above information. Why did they take so long to tell us that?
 
::1/24: Just got the official letter stating the above information. Why did they take so long to tell us that?
   
Line 212: Line 68:
   
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/4 Their deadline was the 1st, so it's probably still too early, they haven't even acknowledged that they received my materials yet.
 
::12/4 Their deadline was the 1st, so it's probably still too early, they haven't even acknowledged that they received my materials yet.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Got an email from them asking for missing letters of rec.
 
::Got an email from them asking for missing letters of rec.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10 Received letter acknowledging receipt of my application, says they HOPE to contact candidates this month about interviews. Do you think that means they're not going to the AHA?
 
::12/10 Received letter acknowledging receipt of my application, says they HOPE to contact candidates this month about interviews. Do you think that means they're not going to the AHA?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::the letter I received says: "we hope to begin contacting candidates about interviews in early January" which I took to mean they are not interviewing at the AHA and will not contact anyone unil January
 
::the letter I received says: "we hope to begin contacting candidates about interviews in early January" which I took to mean they are not interviewing at the AHA and will not contact anyone unil January
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Q: Does anyone know what the teaching load is at E Mich? thanks
 
::Q: Does anyone know what the teaching load is at E Mich? thanks
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/18: scheduled a phone interview for January (x2)
 
::12/18: scheduled a phone interview for January (x2)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/19: from what i can tell on their website, it looks like a 3-3 load. can anyone confirm this?
 
::12/19: from what i can tell on their website, it looks like a 3-3 load. can anyone confirm this?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/19: I looked at the schedule of classes, and that's what it looked like to me, too
 
::12/19: I looked at the schedule of classes, and that's what it looked like to me, too
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/22: If I am not mistaken, it is 4-4 but they commonly do double sections (ie, one class of something like 70 students instead of 2 classes of 35 each). It cuts down a bit on the time in class, but really better questions are how many preps, how many students per semester, and how much teaching outside of your field.
 
::12/22: If I am not mistaken, it is 4-4 but they commonly do double sections (ie, one class of something like 70 students instead of 2 classes of 35 each). It cuts down a bit on the time in class, but really better questions are how many preps, how many students per semester, and how much teaching outside of your field.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/9: The interview went so fast, I wasn't able to ask about the course load--did anyone else? Also, interestingly enough, tenure review is in the 5th year, not the 6th.
 
::1/9: The interview went so fast, I wasn't able to ask about the course load--did anyone else? Also, interestingly enough, tenure review is in the 5th year, not the 6th.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/9: It's 3-3 the first year with no service and 4-4 after that with service expected. Preps varied between 2 to 3 a semester.
 
::1/9: It's 3-3 the first year with no service and 4-4 after that with service expected. Preps varied between 2 to 3 a semester.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Lika123- Is there an interview that you do not have? Good for you! Can I ask what university you are from?
 
:::Lika123- Is there an interview that you do not have? Good for you! Can I ask what university you are from?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/19: Any news?
 
::1/19: Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/20: I haven't heard anything yet, but they did say it would take a couple of weeks to be approved.
 
::1/20: I haven't heard anything yet, but they did say it would take a couple of weeks to be approved.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/25: on-campus scheduled. As to the above, could you clarify, for what to be approved? Thx.
 
::1/25: on-campus scheduled. As to the above, could you clarify, for what to be approved? Thx.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/25: congratulations on the interview. Did they call you today on a Sunday?? Anyway, I just meant for their top choices to be approved by diversity and anyone else in administration.
 
::1/25: congratulations on the interview. Did they call you today on a Sunday?? Anyway, I just meant for their top choices to be approved by diversity and anyone else in administration.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/26: I was also invited for an on campus interview.
 
::1/26: I was also invited for an on campus interview.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/20: offer made
 
::2/20: offer made
   
Line 342: Line 90:
   
 
::11/25: Search possibly postponed - waiting for go-ahead from Univ admin
 
::11/25: Search possibly postponed - waiting for go-ahead from Univ admin
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone have an update about the search going through or not?
 
::Anyone have an update about the search going through or not?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/11: Called for AHA interview.
 
::12/11: Called for AHA interview.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Weird. Other searches have been canceled because of a hiring freeze. What is going on here?
 
::Weird. Other searches have been canceled because of a hiring freeze. What is going on here?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/16. They haven't scheduled campus visits yet, apparently.
 
::1/16. They haven't scheduled campus visits yet, apparently.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/24 Invited for on-campus interview.
 
::1/24 Invited for on-campus interview.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Have they invited all the candidates for campus interviews? How many?
 
::Have they invited all the candidates for campus interviews? How many?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::yeah, pretty sure they have -- three
 
::yeah, pretty sure they have -- three
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::I heard they got a ton of applications from advanced Assistant Profs. Anyone know if this is true? Are they even interviewing fresh PhDs?
 
::I heard they got a ton of applications from advanced Assistant Profs. Anyone know if this is true? Are they even interviewing fresh PhDs?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::I believe they have four on-campus visits - two 'fresh' phds, two advanced asst profs
 
::I believe they have four on-campus visits - two 'fresh' phds, two advanced asst profs
  +
::
  +
::Offer Extended to one of the advanced asst. profs.
  +
::
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=38012 Georgia Gwinnett College]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=38012 Georgia Gwinnett College]
Line 414: Line 111:
   
 
::11/22: rumor - job search canceled
 
::11/22: rumor - job search canceled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/26: That rumor is absolutely 100% untrue. Both senior searches are ongoing.
 
::11/26: That rumor is absolutely 100% untrue. Both senior searches are ongoing.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/9: Harvard Crimson claims all Harvard searches canceled except a "small number of exceptions". Make of it what you will... ([http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=525827 http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=525827])
 
::12/9: Harvard Crimson claims all Harvard searches canceled except a "small number of exceptions". Make of it what you will... ([http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=525827 http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=525827])
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/9 Posted on BRASA yesterday: "Historians of Brazil encouraged to apply: Tenured Professor of Latin American History Harvard University" Lists job as open until filled.
 
::12/9 Posted on BRASA yesterday: "Historians of Brazil encouraged to apply: Tenured Professor of Latin American History Harvard University" Lists job as open until filled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::4 candidates invited to give job talks.
 
::4 candidates invited to give job talks.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Who? (These are senior faculty positions and are public information--so no need to remove the question.)
 
::Who? (These are senior faculty positions and are public information--so no need to remove the question.)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/28: could you please explain what you mean by public information? that is not how i understand the job search process. i know that the names of candidates leak through casual conversations. but do departments actually make these names public? i have never heard of this.
 
::1/28: could you please explain what you mean by public information? that is not how i understand the job search process. i know that the names of candidates leak through casual conversations. but do departments actually make these names public? i have never heard of this.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::The searches that I have been involved with, as candidate and committee member, have all publicly announced candidates. There has never been anything secretive about the process. Job talks were announced (circulated on list-serves and posted with fliers). They have been open to campus members. Is the process different at Harvard? These are senior positions and ALL the senior hires that I have seen have been openly discussed at home and potential institutions.
 
:::The searches that I have been involved with, as candidate and committee member, have all publicly announced candidates. There has never been anything secretive about the process. Job talks were announced (circulated on list-serves and posted with fliers). They have been open to campus members. Is the process different at Harvard? These are senior positions and ALL the senior hires that I have seen have been openly discussed at home and potential institutions.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::In my institution job talks and candidates are generally treated as a semi-confidential event. Announcements go out on our email list-serves, which specifically state it is a job talk. But in flyers in the department the job talk aspect is not mentioned. Nor is the talk listed on the department news website or the Latam Studies website. So it's somewhere in between a public and private event. Any other experiences?
 
::In my institution job talks and candidates are generally treated as a semi-confidential event. Announcements go out on our email list-serves, which specifically state it is a job talk. But in flyers in the department the job talk aspect is not mentioned. Nor is the talk listed on the department news website or the Latam Studies website. So it's somewhere in between a public and private event. Any other experiences?
   
Line 479: Line 128:
   
 
::11/12: Has anyone heard from them yet?
 
::11/12: Has anyone heard from them yet?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/14: received email asking for AA/EOE information
 
::11/14: received email asking for AA/EOE information
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::anything new?
 
::anything new?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/7: Writing sample requested 12/1
 
::12/7: Writing sample requested 12/1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/8: question: a writing sample was part of the original application. does anyone know if they've moved forward beyond trying to get complete applications?
 
::12/8: question: a writing sample was part of the original application. does anyone know if they've moved forward beyond trying to get complete applications?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::By writing sample I meant they asked for the whole dissertation and any articles. They won't be interviewing at the AHA but will invite selected candidates to campus in January.
 
:::By writing sample I meant they asked for the whole dissertation and any articles. They won't be interviewing at the AHA but will invite selected candidates to campus in January.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/8: thanks for the clarification and good luck!
 
::12/8: thanks for the clarification and good luck!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/12: mass "Dear colleague" email that says that they have a short list and we're not on it.
 
::1/12: mass "Dear colleague" email that says that they have a short list and we're not on it.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::So have they invited people for campus interviews?
 
::So have they invited people for campus interviews?
   
Line 539: Line 140:
   
 
::11/28: rumor - AHA interviews scheduled
 
::11/28: rumor - AHA interviews scheduled
  +
:: anything new?
 
 
 
 
 
 
::anything new?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/6: rumor - on campus interviews in progress
 
::12/6: rumor - on campus interviews in progress
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/7: Rumor is true, campus interviews took place first week of December
 
::12/7: Rumor is true, campus interviews took place first week of December
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/14 that was quick--has a hire been made?
 
::12/14 that was quick--has a hire been made?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/14 Hire completed
 
::1/14 Hire completed
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Who was hired?
 
::Who was hired?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::heard it was someone from Harvard
 
::heard it was someone from Harvard
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Wow, I am '''shocked.''' [/sarcasm]
 
::Wow, I am '''shocked.''' [/sarcasm]
   
Line 599: Line 152:
   
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/16: From the SC, they will not be interviewing at the AHAs.
 
::12/16: From the SC, they will not be interviewing at the AHAs.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::What is SC? Search Committee
 
::What is SC? Search Committee
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anything new?
 
::Anything new?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/31: Snail mail rejection letter says that an offer has been made and accepted. How did this happen so quickly, considering that the application deadline wasn't until the middle of December, and they didn't do AHA interviews?
 
::1/31: Snail mail rejection letter says that an offer has been made and accepted. How did this happen so quickly, considering that the application deadline wasn't until the middle of December, and they didn't do AHA interviews?
   
Line 633: Line 162:
   
 
::::Congratulations to Professor Metcalf!!
 
::::Congratulations to Professor Metcalf!!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Any news?
 
::Any news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/4 AHA interview scheduled
 
::12/4 AHA interview scheduled
  +
:: Does anyone else have an interview with Rice?
 
  +
:: Yes.
 
 
 
 
 
::Does anyone else have an interview with Rice?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Yes.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10: Rejection letter received.
 
::12/10: Rejection letter received.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/17- all junior position apps contacted for AHA interviews
 
::12/17- all junior position apps contacted for AHA interviews
  +
:: how do you know this?
 
  +
:: know from email communication that interviews have been set up
how do you know this?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::know from email communication that interviews have been set up
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/7: on campus interview set up
 
::1/7: on campus interview set up
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::3/2 letter rec'd: position filled
 
::3/2 letter rec'd: position filled
   
Line 702: Line 176:
   
 
::11/10: Phone interview scheduled.
 
::11/10: Phone interview scheduled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/12: interview scheduled. Details of interview given. Centers on how to teach a <s>eighth-grade Civics Class</s> core class on democracy using readings from US and Western Europe. Readings include US Constitution, Federalist Papers, and George W. Bush's 2004 inaugural.
 
::11/12: interview scheduled. Details of interview given. Centers on how to teach a <s>eighth-grade Civics Class</s> core class on democracy using readings from US and Western Europe. Readings include US Constitution, Federalist Papers, and George W. Bush's 2004 inaugural.
  +
:: god, that's absurd!
 
 
 
 
 
 
::god, that's absurd!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Interviews have been scheduled even though the application deadline is December 15th?
 
::Interviews have been scheduled even though the application deadline is December 15th?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/6 - yes, they seem to do a kind of rolling interview process (they're not going to AHA - next step will be on-campus)
 
::12/6 - yes, they seem to do a kind of rolling interview process (they're not going to AHA - next step will be on-campus)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/8 - I was contacted about a phone interview for next week; specifications to follow
 
::12/8 - I was contacted about a phone interview for next week; specifications to follow
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::This job is a re-post from last year. Odd rumors from last year.
 
::This job is a re-post from last year. Odd rumors from last year.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/09 - Would anyone care to elaborate on "odd rumors"? I'm supposed to have a phone interview with them next week.
 
::12/09 - Would anyone care to elaborate on "odd rumors"? I'm supposed to have a phone interview with them next week.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/11- Search Suspended until next year.
 
::12/11- Search Suspended until next year.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/11- Yes, I just got the same email.
 
::12/11- Yes, I just got the same email.
   
Line 769: Line 189:
   
 
::11/21: received request for portfolio and writing sample
 
::11/21: received request for portfolio and writing sample
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/16: rec'vd call to schedule an AHA interview
 
::12/16: rec'vd call to schedule an AHA interview
  +
::1/22: Received letter stating that candidates have been chosen for on campus interviews.
 
  +
::Offer made.
 
  +
::Offer accepted
 
 
 
 
::01/22: Received letter stating that candidates have been chosen for on campus interviews.
 
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37259 Shippensburg University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37259 Shippensburg University]
   
 
::12/10 received an email asking for a missing letter of recommendation
 
::12/10 received an email asking for a missing letter of recommendation
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/30 on campus interview scheduled (they're skipping the AHA/phone interview phase)
 
::12/30 on campus interview scheduled (they're skipping the AHA/phone interview phase)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/25: Is anyone else on this wiki interviewing with Shippensburg?
 
::1/25: Is anyone else on this wiki interviewing with Shippensburg?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/3: Offer pending
 
::2/3: Offer pending
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/5: Offer accepted
 
::2/5: Offer accepted
   
Line 819: Line 205:
   
 
::11/23: any word from them? Their deadline was 10/10
 
::11/23: any word from them? Their deadline was 10/10
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/12- Communication with SC: Interviewees to be named soon
 
::12/12- Communication with SC: Interviewees to be named soon
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/15-Can I ask how you found this out? I tried asking for a timeline and the SC wouldn't give me an answer!
 
::12/15-Can I ask how you found this out? I tried asking for a timeline and the SC wouldn't give me an answer!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::-Actually the SC said things are "proceeding as planned" and the department secretary said that nominees should be named soon. (Staff do the real work and know everything).
 
:::-Actually the SC said things are "proceeding as planned" and the department secretary said that nominees should be named soon. (Staff do the real work and know everything).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/16 phone interview scheduled for first week of January. I got the impression that they are not interviewing at AHA
 
::12/16 phone interview scheduled for first week of January. I got the impression that they are not interviewing at AHA
   
Line 851: Line 213:
   
 
::11/18: rec'd request for dissertation chapters
 
::11/18: rec'd request for dissertation chapters
  +
:: have interviews been scheduled for this job?
 
 
 
 
 
 
::have interviews been scheduled for this job?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/13: email rejection received, 3 finalists already chosen
 
::12/13: email rejection received, 3 finalists already chosen
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/16. Have they made a hire?
 
::1/16. Have they made a hire?
  +
:: I hear they made a hire
 
I hear they made a hire
 
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37179 SUNY Stony Brook]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37179 SUNY Stony Brook]
   
 
::does anyone have any news on Stony Brook?
 
::does anyone have any news on Stony Brook?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::(12/19) Just received letter saying search has been suspended due to budget cuts. (Gosh, is anyone at all hiring this year???)
 
::(12/19) Just received letter saying search has been suspended due to budget cuts. (Gosh, is anyone at all hiring this year???)
 
 
 
*Susquehanna University
 
*Susquehanna University
   
 
::11/15: Any word yet?
 
::11/15: Any word yet?
  +
:: Not a peep!
 
  +
:: Still no news? Anyone?
 
 
 
 
 
::Not a peep!
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Still no news? Anyone?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10: Set up an AHA interview-sounds like there might be an inside candidate
 
::12/10: Set up an AHA interview-sounds like there might be an inside candidate
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Why? Please explain
 
:::Why? Please explain
  +
:::I would appreciate if someone could please explain the rumor of an inside candidate. This is very discouraging... <br /> The SC mentioned that there is someone there already teaching Latin American history. I don't know if she's applying or not, but it is something to keep in mind.
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::I would appreciate if someone could please explain the rumor of an inside candidate. This is very discouraging...
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::::The SC mentioned that there is someone there already teaching Latin American history. I don't know if she's applying or not, but it is something to keep in mind.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/7: Campus interview scheduled.
 
::1/7: Campus interview scheduled.
  +
:: Have they already chosen the three finalists for campus interviews? Does anyone know??
 
Have they already chosen the three finalists for campus interviews? Does anyone know??
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/10: I did an AHA interview but haven't heard anything, I assume I was passed over.
 
::1/10: I did an AHA interview but haven't heard anything, I assume I was passed over.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::I know of three people invited to campus visits. They want to make a decision by the end of January or early February.
 
::I know of three people invited to campus visits. They want to make a decision by the end of January or early February.
  +
::Offer made.
  +
:: Does anyone know if the offer was accepted? Has a hire been made?
  +
:: Yes, offer accepted.
  +
::
   
 
*Syracuse University
 
*Syracuse University
   
 
::11/20: Has anyone heard from them? Request for more writing a couple weeks ago...
 
::11/20: Has anyone heard from them? Request for more writing a couple weeks ago...
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::Received the same request at the same time. No communication since. (11/20)
 
::Received the same request at the same time. No communication since. (11/20)
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::Received request 10/31 and have not heard back.
 
::Received request 10/31 and have not heard back.
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::Does anyone have interviews or other news beyond the writing requests?
 
::Does anyone have interviews or other news beyond the writing requests?
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::12/9 scheduled AHA interview
 
::12/9 scheduled AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::Myself and others I know from whom they requested more materials never heard back from them.
 
::Myself and others I know from whom they requested more materials never heard back from them.
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::Campus interview scheduled
 
::Campus interview scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::1/19 Can I ask when they contacted you to schedule the campus interview?
 
::1/19 Can I ask when they contacted you to schedule the campus interview?
   
  +
::I believe it was 1/9
   
  +
::Offer made and accepted.
   
 
 
 
::I believe it was 1/9
 
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36758 Temple University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36758 Temple University]
   
 
::Has anyone heard anything?
 
::Has anyone heard anything?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/4 scheduled AHA interview
 
::12/4 scheduled AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Has anyone heard about campus interviews yet?
 
::Has anyone heard about campus interviews yet?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Yes, campus visit scheduled on 1/9
 
::Yes, campus visit scheduled on 1/9
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Congrats! That's a great job. Anyone know if they called all three candidates?
 
::Congrats! That's a great job. Anyone know if they called all three candidates?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/9 offer made and accepted
 
::2/9 offer made and accepted
  +
::
 
 
 
 
 
 
::What school is the candidate from?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Harvard.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::BIG surprise.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::I've heard that Harvard PhDs don't even really have to interview. Their Campus visits are just long cocktail parties and everybody laughs about how stupid all those non-Harvard PhD's are. Supposedly they don't even have to write their dissertations. They just send in a piece of Harvard letterhead with their signature and the job is theirs. At least that's what I've heard.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Oh, no. Each one is more brilliant than the next. Sure they have to go through the pedestrian tasks of writing and interviewing, but everyone knows that they are far superior to those proletarian Ph.D.s. from state schools. Simply look at the jobs that they get and, of course, remember to note that they went to Harvard.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::3/2 Why beat up on Harvard? Maybe by making it to Harvard--and through the program there--simply means that these PhDs are generally of a higher intellectual level? It's not a class thing (as per the 'proletarian' comment above), it's a talent thing (at least since full funding for grad school started at many schools).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::A "a higher intellectual level" and "talent thing". That is just naively stupid.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::3/3 I think the more important factor here than the Harvard PhD is that the candidate already has several years of experience as an assistant professor. This seems to be common for the assistant professor openings at many of the "better" jobs.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::A how about something more direct: they're smarter and better historians. i think that's what the 3/2 poster was getting at without being direct. what's naively stupid about the idea that harvard phds are likely to be smarter and better historians than "proletarian phds from state schools"?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Several points here: First, having no specific knowledge of the candidate, one should have nothing but praise for a fellow academic getting a job--so congratulations to that person! Second, related to the biases towards those of the Ivy-ilk, the assertion that Harvard historians are just "smarter and better historians" is unbelievably ridiculous that it ''barely'' merits a response (but here goes anyway). Please do tell me what distinguishes an Ivy-league graduate from others. Is it years of generous, committed funding and the lack of competition for grants, scholarships and awards? Or is it, maybe, the absence of real (as in any) teaching experience? Do Ivy-league dissertations have unique Ivy-only sources? Do Ivy-leaguers have special powers of historical analysis that only can be taught, learned, and understood by other Ivy-leaguers? I suspect that, at base, Ivy-leaguers are distinct because they are from the Ivy-leagues (but that may be a tautology and I am from a state school with Ivy-league envy, so I do not know if I can really use a smart word like that). Scholars are scholars, no matter where they come from. Finally, really? REALLY!?!? Some Ivy-leaguers need to figure out that their IP addresses identify their '''exact''' location. One should figure out how the internet works before claiming to be of superior intellect. Please, get over yourself and your Ivy education.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::The fact that Ivy-Leaguers have years of noncompetitive funding and few teaching obligations means that they have more time to work on their research, and, in my experience, most hiring committees are a lot more worried about research accomplishments than teaching experience. So if you have more time and resources to dedicate to your research , isn’t it likely that your research will be better and that you will have been able to finish it in a timely fashion (another major consideration for search committees)? Not to mention that the Harvards of the world have tremendous library and human resources that often can’t be matched by other universities. Now to assume that somebody is just better because they went to Harvard is silly, but I think that’s a straw man. I’ve served on search committees, been privy to the deliberations of others, and nobody is being wowed by Ivy League names alone. Lots of Ivy league candidates wind up way down hiring lists because their work isn’t that great, or they are assholes in the interview, or whatever, but the same is true for people coming from all those terribly underprivileged state institutions like Michigan, Wisconsin, UCLA, Berkeley, Texas, and the rest. But let’s not kid ourselves: many Ivy League candidates are really good because it’s really hard to get into those programs and once you’re in you have tremendous resources at your disposal (just as you do at the top state institutions). To suggest that this doesn’t give those students an edge over the students who are teaching two courses a semester and having to scratch and claw for the money to take a research trip is, frankly, ridiculous.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::::Well, this argument is fundamentally different than claiming that the Ivy-educated are "smarter and better historians." Your so-called straw man has been put out there by an Ivy; the real straw man, if we are going to play on logic, is that tremendous human resources and libraries are what distinguish an Ivy PhD from others. And, lest we forget, two of '''the best''' libraries for Latin America--the Benson and the Bancroft--are at state institutions. Further, it is nothing but a specious argument to claim they are better because they got into Harvard. Is this some kind of claim to objective intelligence and that university admissions and departments are the arbiters of intellect? ''Of course'' there are differences. It seems to me that getting experience teaching in grad school and locating independent sources of funding ON TOP of writing original research is the exact preparation one needs for the academy. Where, except the Ivys, does an academic not have balance teaching, research and funding? Do tell.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::::The Argument is “fundamentally different” because I was responding directly to you. Your words were: “Please do tell me what distinguishes an Ivy-league graduate from others. Is it years of generous, committed funding and the lack of competition for grants, scholarships and awards? Or is it, maybe, the absence of real (as in any) teaching experience?” And the answer was essentially “yes”, that is what distinguishes Ivy candidates (or candidates from the top state schools) from other candidates. Those things end up making many of them very good candidates. And the straw man was basically suggested by various posts, I believe several by you, claiming it “a joke” or a “big surprise” that Harvard candidates got good jobs. Obviously those comments were meant to suggest that Harvard candidates get good jobs just because they are from Harvard. Or did you mean something else? It’s really bizarre that you can’t fathom that the schools with the most money to offer incoming graduate students aren’t going to end up getting many of the best qualified and most outstanding candidates from the undergraduate ranks, unless you think previous performance in college is a completely bogus measure. Let’s try a soccer analogy. In Europe there are big rich teams like Real Madrid and Manchester United that have essentially unlimited resources to pay their players and staff. Those teams go out and try to recruit the very best players with the very best resumes, and since they pay the best and have the most exposure and the best reputations, they get those players, thus they have a higher percentage of players who appeared to have the highest potential whenever they entered the professional ranks. Once they have them, they have more money to invest in them—in the best fitness technologies, in the best team physicians, in the best coaches, in the best everything. So those players not only had better resumes when they joined these clubs, but they then have the added advantage of having the best resources while being pushed by other outstanding teammates. Now inevitably some of those players flame out, disappoint, get lazy, and generally don’t perform up to what was expected, but at the end of the day only someone who is delusional would think that Real Sociedad or Leeds United is going to have as many good players as Real Madrid and Manchester United. Now one of the poorer teams might occasionally find a “late bloomer” who winds up being better than most of the guys on Real Madrid, but it’s more likely that the players from Real Madrid will in general wind up having better careers than those from Real Sociedad. Some version of this is also at work when one is comparing graduate schools, though it’s admittedly much less “efficient” than a pro sports market because how we measure quality academic work is much more subjective than how we measure good soccer players. But that doesn’t mean that these measures are 100% subjective or even 50% subjective. Have you ever served on a admissions committee or a search committee? It’s not a completely random process. There are things like writing samples, letters of recommendation, test scores and grades that take some of the subjectivity out of it. Now if you think all of that stuff is completely bogus, then I guess we might as well agree to disagree.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::::To the actual issue at hand, I have served on hiring committees and know lots of people at or from the Ivys, so my knowledge of this is first hand and not tangential. I also know lots of people in the academy, from a host of different universities. Yes, of course, the Ivys have loads of money and their students have access to resources, but your argument that this inherently makes them better candidates is missed on me. Further, how this defines them as smarter and better historians is equally missed. The wealth of Harvard, Yale and Princeton, by my account, hardly overcomes what often are tremendous gaps in the CVs of many of their grads--namely gaps in teaching experience and external funding. Now, of course, this is not true across the board, but as a whole Ivy grads have little experience in the classroom. A number of faculty from the Ivys that we have hired in my department have come to grad students for advice on teaching. At state schools that lack the deep coffers, grad students are ''forced'' by necessity to seek nationally competitive sources of funding. This, essentially, creates a level of evaluation on projects that may not be there if a well-funded student chooses not to go after additional money. I will stand the CVs of people I know at Berkeley, Texas, Wisconsin, Michigan, Arizona, and UCLA against ''any'' Ivy any day. I have, in fact, seen the CVs of friends from these institutions and those from friends at Harvard and Yale and there is little competition.  There clearly is deference given to many Ivys -- a deference that is ''not'' fundamentally rooted in merit.  Deny it if you like, but it is there nonetheless.  And, by the way, I am always happy to talk about this, but I am now done posting on this topic.(My incorrect statement removed).<br />
 
 
 
 
 
:::::
 
 
 
 
 
:::::Ok, so you are basically saying that you take it for granted that the candidates from these other institutions are pretty much by rule better than those from the Ivys. I get it. So instead of actually showing that there's some ridiculous bias shown in favor of the Ivys you've show, that if you were in charge, there would be a ridiculous bias against the Ivys. Not only that, but there is "little competition" when you compare the two. Amazing. So it's not just that there is a some perhaps not so surprising bias in favor of all of those old and august Ivys, it's that the students from there are actually inferior but have everyone so completely turned around that they actually get all the best jobs! Wow! That's amazing. You should write a book about this. I bet it would get you a really good job.
 
 
 
:::::I have grown tired of your blathering and misreading of my very basic statements. Deny, as you like, that there is a very strong pro-Ivy bias.  And YOU have failed to defend why the Ivy's are "smarter and better historians."  So here is last and final message to you.  Bugger off.
 
 
 
:::::I never argued that the Ivys are, by default, smarter and better historians. That was somebody else, and I certainly never claimed to be defending that argument. I argued that because of the way Ivys can recruit and fund, it stands to reason that more of their candidates will be good candidates in comparison to those from poorly funded state schools. I specifically stated that the wealthy public schools like Michigan, Berkeley, etc. have the same advantages that the Ivys have in this regard. Your argument is that the Ivy students are likely to be less qualified than students at poorly funded state institutions because, at those institutions,  "grad students are forced by necessity to seek nationally competitive sources of funding" which "creates a level of evaluation of projects that may not be there if a well-funded student chooses not to go after additional money." Translation: the poorer your institution, the more outside funding you have to seek, so the higher the "level of evaluation of your projects," which presumably means that your project is going to be better. Basically you're saying that the poverty of some state institutions raises the level of competition for the students in those places because they have to seek national awards, and that this makes them better. And, furthermore, that because they have to teach more, that also makes them better candidates, right? And I'm arguing that the rich institutions have a higher quality incoming group of students because they have the money and funding to be more selective. And, furthermore, that once those students start grad school they compete with a higher qualified crop of peers and they have plenty of funding to spend more time on their research and less time writing grant applications or teaching. And that these factors are more important to producing candidates who are likely to be successful on the job market, first because more time and funding to do actual research is, in my opinion, a good thing and, second, because most search committees don't care that much about teaching experience-- committees are hiring people for potentially 30 years, the fact that some grad student has taught a lot over the last few years doesn't put them very far ahead of the candidates who haven't taught at all. Furthermore, you can evaluate teaching potential pretty well by how somebody interviews and gives a job talk. If they know how to communicate, they know how to communicate.  Finally, you compared your "friends" from the top public schools with those at Harvard and claim that "there is no competition" between the two. Now, admittedly, you're only talking about your friends. But presumably the point is that this reflects a general trend. If that wasn't the intention of the comment, then I'm not sure why you included it.
 
 
 
 
*Texas A&M - Commerce
 
*Texas A&M - Commerce
   
 
::11/13: Phone interview.
 
::11/13: Phone interview.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/19: Campus interview scheduled
 
::11/19: Campus interview scheduled
   
Line 1,184: Line 279:
   
 
::Anyone heard anything?
 
::Anyone heard anything?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10: received rejection letter
 
::12/10: received rejection letter
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/11: scheduled AHA interview
 
::12/11: scheduled AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/23: They have apparently selected their finalists and made invitations to campus. I am among the uninvited.
 
::1/23: They have apparently selected their finalists and made invitations to campus. I am among the uninvited.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/23: I received a call back yesterday (1/22) evening.
 
::1/23: I received a call back yesterday (1/22) evening.
  +
::3/23: Offer made and accepted.
   
 
*United States Naval Academy
 
*United States Naval Academy
   
 
::11/12: phone interview
 
::11/12: phone interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/17: requested on campus interview
 
::11/17: requested on campus interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Any more news?
 
::Any more news?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Campus interview completed.
 
::Campus interview completed.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/26 email rejection. offer made to and accepted by another candidate.
 
::12/26 email rejection. offer made to and accepted by another candidate.
   
Line 1,255: Line 297:
   
 
::has anyone heard?
 
::has anyone heard?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/20 Rejection letter received
 
::12/20 Rejection letter received
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/8 Received request for campus visit
 
::1/8 Received request for campus visit
   
Line 1,273: Line 303:
   
 
::letter sent to history lists saying deadline is Dec. 15th not the 1st as previously listed
 
::letter sent to history lists saying deadline is Dec. 15th not the 1st as previously listed
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/17 Email to set up AHA interview
 
::12/17 Email to set up AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2 candidates invited for on-campus interviews
 
::2 candidates invited for on-campus interviews
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Just two? Isn't that odd?
 
:::Just two? Isn't that odd?
  +
::2/26 offer made and accepted by Sylvia Sellers-Garcia (identified in letter from SC)
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/26 offer made and accepted
 
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36602 University of Denver]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36602 University of Denver]
   
 
::12/3 AHA interviews scheduled
 
::12/3 AHA interviews scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/22 rejection letter received
 
::12/22 rejection letter received
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/6 offer made and accepted
 
::2/6 offer made and accepted
   
Line 1,323: Line 317:
   
 
::12/8 AHA interview scheduled
 
::12/8 AHA interview scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/9 AHA interview scheduled
 
::12/9 AHA interview scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/25 on-campus interview scheduled
 
::1/25 on-campus interview scheduled
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/24 offer made & accepted
 
::2/24 offer made & accepted
   
Line 1,353: Line 329:
   
 
::Anyone heard yet?
 
::Anyone heard yet?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Received email ack.
 
::Received email ack.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/8: AHA interview scheduled.
 
::12/8: AHA interview scheduled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/12 On-campus interview scheduled.
 
::1/12 On-campus interview scheduled.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone know if they have contacted all the on-campus interviewees?
 
::Anyone know if they have contacted all the on-campus interviewees?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Received email saying three candidates were chosen for campus visits.
 
::Received email saying three candidates were chosen for campus visits.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/4: Offer made.
 
::2/4: Offer made.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Offer accepted by candidate #2.
 
::Offer accepted by candidate #2.
   
Line 1,410: Line 344:
   
 
::11/10: rejection received; letter said that the list of finalists to interview has been determined
 
::11/10: rejection received; letter said that the list of finalists to interview has been determined
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/19: yes, i received the same letter a couple of days ago.
 
::11/19: yes, i received the same letter a couple of days ago.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/21: Manuscript requested @ 1st of Nov, heard nothing since.
 
::11/21: Manuscript requested @ 1st of Nov, heard nothing since.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/22: search canceled, possibly reopen next year
 
::11/22: search canceled, possibly reopen next year
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/25: Notified that I was a finalist, but the search has been suspended (but not yet canceled). SC stated that the search may move forward later in the year (but I wouldn't count on it).
 
::11/25: Notified that I was a finalist, but the search has been suspended (but not yet canceled). SC stated that the search may move forward later in the year (but I wouldn't count on it).
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::jeez, that sucks. 12/02
 
::jeez, that sucks. 12/02
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::I never heard anything from them--no rejection, no request for more materials, nothing.
 
::I never heard anything from them--no rejection, no request for more materials, nothing.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Got the same as above: request for materials, confirmed short list, search suspended.
 
::Got the same as above: request for materials, confirmed short list, search suspended.
   
Line 1,463: Line 355:
   
 
::11/19: received email re: an AHA interview; they also requested writing sample.
 
::11/19: received email re: an AHA interview; they also requested writing sample.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/19: received email scheduling AHA interview and requesting writing sample
 
::11/19: received email scheduling AHA interview and requesting writing sample
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/7: on campus interview scheduled (X2)
 
::1/7: on campus interview scheduled (X2)
  +
:::Congrats! That was an absolutely ''brutal'' interview. <br />Rejection letter received. Details that an offer accepted by Manuella Meyer from Yale.
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Congrats! That was an absolutely ''brutal'' interview.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:Rejection letter received. Details that an offer accepted by Manuella Meyer from Yale.
 
 
 
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37323 University of Texas Permian Basin]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37323 University of Texas Permian Basin]
   
Line 1,501: Line 366:
   
 
::11/14: rec'd call to schedule AHA interview
 
::11/14: rec'd call to schedule AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::11/17: Also rec'd call for AHA interview
 
::11/17: Also rec'd call for AHA interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/15: I never heard from them. (12/17: rejection letter received)
 
::12/15: I never heard from them. (12/17: rejection letter received)
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/15: rejection letter received
 
::12/15: rejection letter received
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
::Anyone heard about campus interviews?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/14: scheduled campus interview
 
::1/14: scheduled campus interview
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Anyone else? Have they called all of their candidates?
 
::Anyone else? Have they called all of their candidates?
  +
:: Yes.
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Yes.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::1/19: Generic (Dear Dr/Mr/Ms ... it is a cliche to say we had outstanding candidates, but we had outstanding...) rejection message received.
 
::1/19: Generic (Dear Dr/Mr/Ms ... it is a cliche to say we had outstanding candidates, but we had outstanding...) rejection message received.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::2/11 offer made.
 
::2/11 offer made.
  +
::Anyone know if the offer was accepted?
  +
:: Offer accepted
   
 
*Villanova University
 
*Villanova University
   
 
::11/17: Search Canceled due to budget constraints
 
::11/17: Search Canceled due to budget constraints
  +
:: got the same confirmation
 
 
 
 
 
 
::got the same confirmation
 
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37867 Wabash College]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=37867 Wabash College]
Line 1,581: Line 388:
   
 
::11/12, the search has been canceled b/c of budget constraints
 
::11/12, the search has been canceled b/c of budget constraints
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::pretty scary. i assume we'll be seeing more cancellations as the economic crisis rolls on?
 
:::pretty scary. i assume we'll be seeing more cancellations as the economic crisis rolls on?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::--yeah, you're probably right
 
:::--yeah, you're probably right
   
 
====Caribbean History====
 
====Caribbean History====
 
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36877 East Carolina University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36877 East Carolina University]
 
:*application deadline is 15 Oct 2008
 
:*application deadline is 15 Oct 2008
Line 1,604: Line 398:
   
 
::Anyone hear anything?
 
::Anyone hear anything?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/11 - Contacted about scheduling AHA interview; also asked for more written work
 
::12/11 - Contacted about scheduling AHA interview; also asked for more written work
   
Line 1,618: Line 406:
   
 
::12/3 scheduled interview at AHA about two weeks ago
 
::12/3 scheduled interview at AHA about two weeks ago
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::Campus Interview Scheduled 1/5
 
::Campus Interview Scheduled 1/5
   
  +
<!-- unsupported placeholder type -->Mexican History====''I would be leery of the prospects of these universities actually hiring. AZ, CA, & FL are all in a miserable financial position these days--the worst in the country in fact. The University of Arizona has an official hiring freeze and ASU seems headed in that direction. FSU canceled the search last year because of financial constraints. ''&lt;/sadness&gt;
====Mexican History====
 
''I would be leery of the prospects of these universities actually hiring. AZ, CA, & FL are all in a miserable financial position these days--the worst in the country in fact. The University of Arizona has an official hiring freeze and ASU seems headed in that direction. FSU canceled the search last year because of financial constraints. ''&lt;/sadness&gt;
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
:--I guess one thing we need to figure out is: are these hard or soft freezes? My understanding is that hard freeze means that no positions will be approved at all. A soft freeze is that each position will be reviewed individually for their "importance" and will be decided on a case-by-case basis.
 
:--I guess one thing we need to figure out is: are these hard or soft freezes? My understanding is that hard freeze means that no positions will be approved at all. A soft freeze is that each position will be reviewed individually for their "importance" and will be decided on a case-by-case basis.
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::From what I've heard from my "sources" at ASU, things are bad but they're leaning more toward the soft freeze you just described... 12/2
 
::From what I've heard from my "sources" at ASU, things are bad but they're leaning more toward the soft freeze you just described... 12/2
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::12/3:- any ideas which jobs at ASU would go and which would be cut? They have 4, 3 of them related to Latin America (Mexico, Latino/a, Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora, and US Native Americans)
 
::12/3:- any ideas which jobs at ASU would go and which would be cut? They have 4, 3 of them related to Latin America (Mexico, Latino/a, Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora, and US Native Americans)
 
 
 
 
 
 
   
 
::12/08:- no, my "source" is a close family member who works in one of the science departments. so it could be a completely different animal. sorry i can't help more.
 
::12/08:- no, my "source" is a close family member who works in one of the science departments. so it could be a completely different animal. sorry i can't help more.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/10:-that's ok, better than no info at all-thanks for sharing!
 
::12/10:-that's ok, better than no info at all-thanks for sharing!
   
Line 1,671: Line 422:
   
 
::Any word?
 
::Any word?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Nothing yet
 
:::Nothing yet
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::Canceled last week
 
:::Canceled last week
 
:::* Just this job? Anyone know if the other history searches at ASU have been canceled too? And what of ASU-West?
 
:::* Just this job? Anyone know if the other history searches at ASU have been canceled too? And what of ASU-West?
 
:::How did you hear?--I haven't gotten a call, letter, or email
 
:::How did you hear?--I haven't gotten a call, letter, or email
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:::I'm not the person who posted that the job was canceled--I'd still like to hear where you heard, just to be sure--but according to a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West, who emailed my advisor, ASU lost its lines, ASU West did not.
 
:::I'm not the person who posted that the job was canceled--I'd still like to hear where you heard, just to be sure--but according to a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West, who emailed my advisor, ASU lost its lines, ASU West did not.
  +
:::12/18 I just heard that I got an on-campus at ASU, but for the Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora job, not the Mexican job.
 
12/18 I just heard that I got an on-campus at ASU, but for the Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora job, not the Mexican job.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
:Wow, congrats on that. Has anyone applying to the Mexico search heard anything official? If it was canceled a week ago, why haven't they told us?
 
:Wow, congrats on that. Has anyone applying to the Mexico search heard anything official? If it was canceled a week ago, why haven't they told us?
   
Line 1,713: Line 439:
   
 
*Cal State Los Angeles
 
*Cal State Los Angeles
  +
*What is happening with CSLA? Anyone know?
  +
Offer made and accepted in late Jan.
  +
   
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36654 Florida State University]
 
*[http://www.h-net.org/jobs/display_job.php?jobID=36654 Florida State University]
Line 1,718: Line 447:
   
 
::--Hiring Freeze Rumored on this job.
 
::--Hiring Freeze Rumored on this job.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
::12/6: AHA interview scheduled
 
::12/6: AHA interview scheduled
 
 
   
 
==Rumors & Rumors of Rumors ==
 
==Rumors & Rumors of Rumors ==
 
 
*I am seriously scared that only a handful of these universities are going to hire. The existing cancellations from major universities, such as Villanova and Pitt, and supposed freezes at others, including Emory and ASU, combined with the silence from other schools, like Central Michigan and Susquehanna, have me ''rattled''. Big State, Small Private, Big Private, Small State--it seems to be tough across the board.
 
*I am seriously scared that only a handful of these universities are going to hire. The existing cancellations from major universities, such as Villanova and Pitt, and supposed freezes at others, including Emory and ASU, combined with the silence from other schools, like Central Michigan and Susquehanna, have me ''rattled''. Big State, Small Private, Big Private, Small State--it seems to be tough across the board.
   
Line 1,750: Line 470:
 
:*I am on a search committee for my big state university. The President announced a hiring freeze this week, but the 4 open searches in the whole of our College of A&S are still in limbo. It appears we may still be able to make a hire, but I will ultimately be surprised if it happens. As much as I'd like to have had interviews at a few of the searches that were cancelled, I'm just thankful to have a job. I also wouldn't be surprised if searches went as far as campus visits, offers made and accepted, and then had those positions revoked as the true depths of the coming years budget shortfalls. One last thing-- we are likely losing all of our adjuncts and lecturers, who do significant teaching, so it's not as simple as moving to adjunct labor. We're moving to fewer seats.
 
:*I am on a search committee for my big state university. The President announced a hiring freeze this week, but the 4 open searches in the whole of our College of A&S are still in limbo. It appears we may still be able to make a hire, but I will ultimately be surprised if it happens. As much as I'd like to have had interviews at a few of the searches that were cancelled, I'm just thankful to have a job. I also wouldn't be surprised if searches went as far as campus visits, offers made and accepted, and then had those positions revoked as the true depths of the coming years budget shortfalls. One last thing-- we are likely losing all of our adjuncts and lecturers, who do significant teaching, so it's not as simple as moving to adjunct labor. We're moving to fewer seats.
   
:<nowiki>*</nowiki>The previous post is depressing...Can we update this wiki and inform everyone when/if any offers are made?? Thanks in advance.
+
:The previous post is depressing...Can we update this wiki and inform everyone when/if any offers are made?? Thanks in advance.
 
* Are we going to identify the people who accept offers? It is common on the other Wikis (see: Art History for example)
 
* Are we going to identify the people who accept offers? It is common on the other Wikis (see: Art History for example)
   
Line 1,756: Line 476:
   
 
::1/21. I don't see that there's anything wrong with writing the names of those who have accepted jobs. It's information that is now public if not yet publicized. It's useful to know, for instance, who is no longer a likely a candidate for another job that may not have made a hire yet.
 
::1/21. I don't see that there's anything wrong with writing the names of those who have accepted jobs. It's information that is now public if not yet publicized. It's useful to know, for instance, who is no longer a likely a candidate for another job that may not have made a hire yet.
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
   
   
Line 1,761: Line 490:
   
 
::1/21: I am with you. Once there is a hire, it is public knowledge. Transparency does not end when there is a pending offer.
 
::1/21: I am with you. Once there is a hire, it is public knowledge. Transparency does not end when there is a pending offer.
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
  +
   
   

Latest revision as of 20:10, 27 April 2009

Did someone delete the whole page? Or did the switch to this new editor somehow erase the page?

GOOD LUCK AHA INTERVIEWEES!!!


Latin American History[]

any news?
12/07 -- I was contacted a couple of days ago about scheduling an AHA interview
12/10: email rejection letter received
12/09: rejection letter received via email
12/19: rejection letter by email
1/8: Campus visit scheduled
1/21; Rejection email received
Any news?
(12/4) Their deadline isn't until 12/12 (which is annoying considering they're going to the AHA).
(12/16) Apparently this search is still progressing, although ASU Main's searches were canceled--a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West emailed my advisor--apparently the final decision for interviewees will be made on Wed. and forwarded to the dean--I don't know the timeline from there
12/18 Interview scheduled.
1/12 Invited for on-campus interview
3/9 Offer made
3/17 Offer accepted
Any news?
12/15-- no news.
Anyone know who is the SC? There was not one at the time of the application.
12/17 AHA interview scheduled.
Anyone heard about campus interviews?
01/23 Received phone call for on-campus interview. (X2)
3/14 Offer accepted by Jonathan Truitt (identified in letter from SC)
12/3 scheduled interview at AHA today
1/7 Campus visit scheduled
Candidate accepted offer
Any news?
(12/4) I received the AA/EOE form a couple of weeks ago, but nothing other than that
12/6 AHA interview scheduled (x3)
Does the (x3) mean three people have scheduled interviews? Thanks, in advance, for the clarification! Yes.
Does any one know what is happening with Colgate have they sent all of their interview/rejection letters yet (12/20/08)?
No, and I have emailed to ask. No communication of any sort. That is real classy
Campus interview scheduled
4/20 got a letter today saying that no one was hired. And just the other day I noticed that they posted a VAP opening. Any idea what's going on?

4/27 They are hiring for a one-year position, and most likely doing the search again next year.

12/4 phone interview
12/14 from the SC, search is "on hold"
12/15 Any indication why or what the timeline is?
12/16 Few details provided by the SC, but the impression I got was that it is related to financial matters (big surprise).
1/24: Just got the official letter stating the above information. Why did they take so long to tell us that?
Any news?
12/4 Their deadline was the 1st, so it's probably still too early, they haven't even acknowledged that they received my materials yet.
Got an email from them asking for missing letters of rec.
12/10 Received letter acknowledging receipt of my application, says they HOPE to contact candidates this month about interviews. Do you think that means they're not going to the AHA?
the letter I received says: "we hope to begin contacting candidates about interviews in early January" which I took to mean they are not interviewing at the AHA and will not contact anyone unil January
Q: Does anyone know what the teaching load is at E Mich? thanks
12/18: scheduled a phone interview for January (x2)
12/19: from what i can tell on their website, it looks like a 3-3 load. can anyone confirm this?
12/19: I looked at the schedule of classes, and that's what it looked like to me, too
12/22: If I am not mistaken, it is 4-4 but they commonly do double sections (ie, one class of something like 70 students instead of 2 classes of 35 each). It cuts down a bit on the time in class, but really better questions are how many preps, how many students per semester, and how much teaching outside of your field.
1/9: The interview went so fast, I wasn't able to ask about the course load--did anyone else? Also, interestingly enough, tenure review is in the 5th year, not the 6th.
1/9: It's 3-3 the first year with no service and 4-4 after that with service expected. Preps varied between 2 to 3 a semester.
Lika123- Is there an interview that you do not have? Good for you! Can I ask what university you are from?
1/19: Any news?
1/20: I haven't heard anything yet, but they did say it would take a couple of weeks to be approved.
1/25: on-campus scheduled. As to the above, could you clarify, for what to be approved? Thx.
1/25: congratulations on the interview. Did they call you today on a Sunday?? Anyway, I just meant for their top choices to be approved by diversity and anyone else in administration.
1/26: I was also invited for an on campus interview.
2/20: offer made
11/25: Search possibly postponed - waiting for go-ahead from Univ admin
Anyone have an update about the search going through or not?
12/11: Called for AHA interview.
Weird. Other searches have been canceled because of a hiring freeze. What is going on here?
1/16. They haven't scheduled campus visits yet, apparently.
1/24 Invited for on-campus interview.
Have they invited all the candidates for campus interviews? How many?
yeah, pretty sure they have -- three
I heard they got a ton of applications from advanced Assistant Profs. Anyone know if this is true? Are they even interviewing fresh PhDs?
I believe they have four on-campus visits - two 'fresh' phds, two advanced asst profs
Offer Extended to one of the advanced asst. profs.
  • The 35th member of the University System of Georgia.
  • PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS: Position requires local travel. Ability to lift and carry files and materials. Ability to move from one office to another office on campus. Adequate vision, hearing and manual dexterity to interact with people in person, on the phone and in writing. Job takes place in normal environmental conditions.
  • I just had to add this. It is the 35th member and the PHYSICAL REQUIREMENTS are so minimal. I really want to talk to someone about this job. Do you have to demonstrate your physical prowess in an interview? That would be great.
11/22: rumor - job search canceled
11/26: That rumor is absolutely 100% untrue. Both senior searches are ongoing.
12/9: Harvard Crimson claims all Harvard searches canceled except a "small number of exceptions". Make of it what you will... (http://www.thecrimson.com/article.aspx?ref=525827)
12/9 Posted on BRASA yesterday: "Historians of Brazil encouraged to apply: Tenured Professor of Latin American History Harvard University" Lists job as open until filled.
4 candidates invited to give job talks.
Who? (These are senior faculty positions and are public information--so no need to remove the question.)
1/28: could you please explain what you mean by public information? that is not how i understand the job search process. i know that the names of candidates leak through casual conversations. but do departments actually make these names public? i have never heard of this.
The searches that I have been involved with, as candidate and committee member, have all publicly announced candidates. There has never been anything secretive about the process. Job talks were announced (circulated on list-serves and posted with fliers). They have been open to campus members. Is the process different at Harvard? These are senior positions and ALL the senior hires that I have seen have been openly discussed at home and potential institutions.
In my institution job talks and candidates are generally treated as a semi-confidential event. Announcements go out on our email list-serves, which specifically state it is a job talk. But in flyers in the department the job talk aspect is not mentioned. Nor is the talk listed on the department news website or the Latam Studies website. So it's somewhere in between a public and private event. Any other experiences?

1/30 Only two of the four candidates are Harvard Ph.Ds this time! What a joke.

  • application deadline is 15 Oct 2008
11/12: Has anyone heard from them yet?
11/14: received email asking for AA/EOE information
anything new?
12/7: Writing sample requested 12/1
12/8: question: a writing sample was part of the original application. does anyone know if they've moved forward beyond trying to get complete applications?
By writing sample I meant they asked for the whole dissertation and any articles. They won't be interviewing at the AHA but will invite selected candidates to campus in January.
12/8: thanks for the clarification and good luck!
1/12: mass "Dear colleague" email that says that they have a short list and we're not on it.
So have they invited people for campus interviews?
  • Princeton University
11/28: rumor - AHA interviews scheduled
anything new?
12/6: rumor - on campus interviews in progress
12/7: Rumor is true, campus interviews took place first week of December
12/14 that was quick--has a hire been made?
1/14 Hire completed
Who was hired?
heard it was someone from Harvard
Wow, I am shocked. [/sarcasm]
Any news?
12/16: From the SC, they will not be interviewing at the AHAs.
What is SC? Search Committee
Anything new?
1/31: Snail mail rejection letter says that an offer has been made and accepted. How did this happen so quickly, considering that the application deadline wasn't until the middle of December, and they didn't do AHA interviews?
  • Rice University
  • Senior hire completed. (Brazil)
  • Let's dispense with the mystery here: Alida Metcalf hired.
Congratulations to Professor Metcalf!!
Any news?
12/4 AHA interview scheduled
Does anyone else have an interview with Rice?
Yes.
12/10: Rejection letter received.
12/17- all junior position apps contacted for AHA interviews
how do you know this?
know from email communication that interviews have been set up
1/7: on campus interview set up
3/2 letter rec'd: position filled
11/10: Phone interview scheduled.
11/12: interview scheduled. Details of interview given. Centers on how to teach a eighth-grade Civics Class core class on democracy using readings from US and Western Europe. Readings include US Constitution, Federalist Papers, and George W. Bush's 2004 inaugural.
god, that's absurd!
Interviews have been scheduled even though the application deadline is December 15th?
12/6 - yes, they seem to do a kind of rolling interview process (they're not going to AHA - next step will be on-campus)
12/8 - I was contacted about a phone interview for next week; specifications to follow
This job is a re-post from last year. Odd rumors from last year.
12/09 - Would anyone care to elaborate on "odd rumors"? I'm supposed to have a phone interview with them next week.
12/11- Search Suspended until next year.
12/11- Yes, I just got the same email.
  • Roosevelt University
11/21: received request for portfolio and writing sample
12/16: rec'vd call to schedule an AHA interview
1/22: Received letter stating that candidates have been chosen for on campus interviews.
Offer made.
Offer accepted
12/10 received an email asking for a missing letter of recommendation
12/30 on campus interview scheduled (they're skipping the AHA/phone interview phase)
1/25: Is anyone else on this wiki interviewing with Shippensburg?
2/3: Offer pending
2/5: Offer accepted
  • St. Xavier University
11/23: any word from them? Their deadline was 10/10
12/12- Communication with SC: Interviewees to be named soon
12/15-Can I ask how you found this out? I tried asking for a timeline and the SC wouldn't give me an answer!
-Actually the SC said things are "proceeding as planned" and the department secretary said that nominees should be named soon. (Staff do the real work and know everything).
12/16 phone interview scheduled for first week of January. I got the impression that they are not interviewing at AHA
  • SUNY Buffalo
11/18: rec'd request for dissertation chapters
have interviews been scheduled for this job?
12/13: email rejection received, 3 finalists already chosen
1/16. Have they made a hire?
I hear they made a hire
does anyone have any news on Stony Brook?
(12/19) Just received letter saying search has been suspended due to budget cuts. (Gosh, is anyone at all hiring this year???)
  • Susquehanna University
11/15: Any word yet?
Not a peep!
Still no news? Anyone?
12/10: Set up an AHA interview-sounds like there might be an inside candidate
Why? Please explain
I would appreciate if someone could please explain the rumor of an inside candidate. This is very discouraging...
The SC mentioned that there is someone there already teaching Latin American history. I don't know if she's applying or not, but it is something to keep in mind.
1/7: Campus interview scheduled.
Have they already chosen the three finalists for campus interviews? Does anyone know??
1/10: I did an AHA interview but haven't heard anything, I assume I was passed over.
I know of three people invited to campus visits. They want to make a decision by the end of January or early February.
Offer made.
Does anyone know if the offer was accepted? Has a hire been made?
Yes, offer accepted.
  • Syracuse University
11/20: Has anyone heard from them? Request for more writing a couple weeks ago...
Received the same request at the same time. No communication since. (11/20)
Received request 10/31 and have not heard back.
Does anyone have interviews or other news beyond the writing requests?
12/9 scheduled AHA interview
Myself and others I know from whom they requested more materials never heard back from them.
Campus interview scheduled
1/19 Can I ask when they contacted you to schedule the campus interview?
I believe it was 1/9
Offer made and accepted.


Has anyone heard anything?
12/4 scheduled AHA interview
Has anyone heard about campus interviews yet?
Yes, campus visit scheduled on 1/9
Congrats! That's a great job. Anyone know if they called all three candidates?
2/9 offer made and accepted
  • Texas A&M - Commerce
11/13: Phone interview.
11/19: Campus interview scheduled
Anyone heard anything?
12/10: received rejection letter
12/11: scheduled AHA interview
Anyone heard about campus interviews?
1/23: They have apparently selected their finalists and made invitations to campus. I am among the uninvited.
1/23: I received a call back yesterday (1/22) evening.
3/23: Offer made and accepted.
  • United States Naval Academy
11/12: phone interview
11/17: requested on campus interview
Any more news?
Campus interview completed.
12/26 email rejection. offer made to and accepted by another candidate.
  • University of Alberta
has anyone heard?
12/20 Rejection letter received
1/8 Received request for campus visit
letter sent to history lists saying deadline is Dec. 15th not the 1st as previously listed
12/17 Email to set up AHA interview
2 candidates invited for on-campus interviews
Just two? Isn't that odd?
2/26 offer made and accepted by Sylvia Sellers-Garcia (identified in letter from SC)
12/3 AHA interviews scheduled
12/22 rejection letter received
2/6 offer made and accepted
12/8 AHA interview scheduled
12/9 AHA interview scheduled
1/25 on-campus interview scheduled
2/24 offer made & accepted
  • application deadline is 17 Nov 2008
Search suspended due to budget restraints; probable reopening of search in 2009-2010
Anyone heard yet?
Received email ack.
12/8: AHA interview scheduled.
1/12 On-campus interview scheduled.
Anyone know if they have contacted all the on-campus interviewees?
Received email saying three candidates were chosen for campus visits.
2/4: Offer made.
Offer accepted by candidate #2.
  • Deadline Feb. 1, 2009
  • application deadline is 15 Oct 2008
11/10: rejection received; letter said that the list of finalists to interview has been determined
11/19: yes, i received the same letter a couple of days ago.
11/21: Manuscript requested @ 1st of Nov, heard nothing since.
11/22: search canceled, possibly reopen next year
11/25: Notified that I was a finalist, but the search has been suspended (but not yet canceled). SC stated that the search may move forward later in the year (but I wouldn't count on it).
jeez, that sucks. 12/02
I never heard anything from them--no rejection, no request for more materials, nothing.
Got the same as above: request for materials, confirmed short list, search suspended.
  • University of Richmond
11/19: received email re: an AHA interview; they also requested writing sample.
11/19: received email scheduling AHA interview and requesting writing sample
1/7: on campus interview scheduled (X2)
Congrats! That was an absolutely brutal interview.
Rejection letter received. Details that an offer accepted by Manuella Meyer from Yale.
  • application deadline is 8 Nov 2008
11/14: rec'd call to schedule AHA interview
11/17: Also rec'd call for AHA interview
12/15: I never heard from them. (12/17: rejection letter received)
12/15: rejection letter received
Anyone heard about campus interviews?
1/14: scheduled campus interview
Anyone else? Have they called all of their candidates?
Yes.
1/19: Generic (Dear Dr/Mr/Ms ... it is a cliche to say we had outstanding candidates, but we had outstanding...) rejection message received.
2/11 offer made.
Anyone know if the offer was accepted?
Offer accepted
  • Villanova University
11/17: Search Canceled due to budget constraints
got the same confirmation
  • William Patterson University
11/12, the search has been canceled b/c of budget constraints
pretty scary. i assume we'll be seeing more cancellations as the economic crisis rolls on?
--yeah, you're probably right

Caribbean History[]

  • application deadline is 15 Oct 2008
Anyone hear anything?
12/11 - Contacted about scheduling AHA interview; also asked for more written work
  • Naval Academy
  • application deadline is 7 Nov 2008
12/3 scheduled interview at AHA about two weeks ago
Campus Interview Scheduled 1/5

Mexican History====I would be leery of the prospects of these universities actually hiring. AZ, CA, & FL are all in a miserable financial position these days--the worst in the country in fact. The University of Arizona has an official hiring freeze and ASU seems headed in that direction. FSU canceled the search last year because of financial constraints. </sadness>

--I guess one thing we need to figure out is: are these hard or soft freezes? My understanding is that hard freeze means that no positions will be approved at all. A soft freeze is that each position will be reviewed individually for their "importance" and will be decided on a case-by-case basis.
From what I've heard from my "sources" at ASU, things are bad but they're leaning more toward the soft freeze you just described... 12/2
12/3:- any ideas which jobs at ASU would go and which would be cut? They have 4, 3 of them related to Latin America (Mexico, Latino/a, Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora, and US Native Americans)
12/08:- no, my "source" is a close family member who works in one of the science departments. so it could be a completely different animal. sorry i can't help more.
12/10:-that's ok, better than no info at all-thanks for sharing!
  • Arizona State University
Any word?
Nothing yet
Canceled last week
  • Just this job? Anyone know if the other history searches at ASU have been canceled too? And what of ASU-West?
How did you hear?--I haven't gotten a call, letter, or email
I'm not the person who posted that the job was canceled--I'd still like to hear where you heard, just to be sure--but according to a History Dept. Prof. at ASU West, who emailed my advisor, ASU lost its lines, ASU West did not.
12/18 I just heard that I got an on-campus at ASU, but for the Judeo-Hispanic Diaspora job, not the Mexican job.
Wow, congrats on that. Has anyone applying to the Mexico search heard anything official? If it was canceled a week ago, why haven't they told us?

12/22: Just got the official email stating that the Modern Mexico search was canceled for budget reasons. There is no indication if they think they'll get the green light next year. The email also stated that they had created their long list, but it didn't say if I was included. Just curious: did anyone ever get an indication if they were on that list?? Thanks!

  • Cal State Fullerton
12/3: AHA interview scheduled

Cal State Fullerton has had on-campus and made an accepted offer.

  • Cal State Los Angeles
  • What is happening with CSLA? Anyone know?

Offer made and accepted in late Jan.


  • application deadline is 1 Nov 2008
--Hiring Freeze Rumored on this job.
12/6: AHA interview scheduled

Rumors & Rumors of Rumors[]

  • I am seriously scared that only a handful of these universities are going to hire. The existing cancellations from major universities, such as Villanova and Pitt, and supposed freezes at others, including Emory and ASU, combined with the silence from other schools, like Central Michigan and Susquehanna, have me rattled. Big State, Small Private, Big Private, Small State--it seems to be tough across the board.
  • Anyone know of any other freezes that are pending?
I have heard rumor that the UDenver job is in limbo because the US has been/is being canceled.
  • I'm at a medium sized comprehensive university (a few years in) and our dean just cancelled 1/3 of the searches this year, so it looks like this is across the board in the profession.
OK, cancel that earlier happy thought (i.e. only some searches cancelled). Things are indeed looking extremely dire. Our provost just froze all hires--just in time for the holidays. Nice. and Classy too!
  • Do you all think places would cancel searches even after going to the expense of an AHA trip?
  • Unfortunately it is possible, budgets are related to projected enrollments for one thing.
  • Enrollment is but one issue. State budgets and private endowments are down everywhere, which often directly affect the funds for new hires, particularly tenure track.
  • One thing I've heard is that some schools may interview at AHA, but send a smaller team -- maybe even one person! -- to conduct the interviews. Don't know about canceling after AHA though. My real fear is that this recession will be so long and serious that some places will simply move to adjunct labor and stay there.
  • Yes, it is not uncommon for departments interview at the AHAs, but then not hire. This was the case for the FSU job last year.
  • I am on a search committee for my big state university. The President announced a hiring freeze this week, but the 4 open searches in the whole of our College of A&S are still in limbo. It appears we may still be able to make a hire, but I will ultimately be surprised if it happens. As much as I'd like to have had interviews at a few of the searches that were cancelled, I'm just thankful to have a job. I also wouldn't be surprised if searches went as far as campus visits, offers made and accepted, and then had those positions revoked as the true depths of the coming years budget shortfalls. One last thing-- we are likely losing all of our adjuncts and lecturers, who do significant teaching, so it's not as simple as moving to adjunct labor. We're moving to fewer seats.
The previous post is depressing...Can we update this wiki and inform everyone when/if any offers are made?? Thanks in advance.
  • Are we going to identify the people who accept offers? It is common on the other Wikis (see: Art History for example)
  • I don't think we need to identify people who accept offers. We're in a job market that lacks transparency and a streamline process. These factors and the current recession doesn't help us. I'm suggesting that we alert each other when offers are being made, in negotiation or rejected (as was done last year) so that we know how to best proceed in these tough economic times.
1/21. I don't see that there's anything wrong with writing the names of those who have accepted jobs. It's information that is now public if not yet publicized. It's useful to know, for instance, who is no longer a likely a candidate for another job that may not have made a hire yet.







1/21: I am with you. Once there is a hire, it is public knowledge. Transparency does not end when there is a pending offer.








1/28: I would urge everyone to err on the side of caution here. It's hard for anyone except the people directly involved to know when a contract has been finalized. It may be the case that the candidate hasn't yet informed his/her home institution about the offer or even that he/she is on the market this year. It would be very unfortunate for this to be revealed because of wiki discussion or speculation. I think it's best to limit the information here to whether an offer has been made, accepted, rejected. We don't get much from knowing who the lucky candidate is (compared with the damage that might be done). We'll all know soon enough, when the faculty profiles are updated.


  • Florida Gulf Coast has an inside candidate for the job they advertised.
  • -that makes sense was in Fla over Xmas; offered to visit campus -they didn't show any interest-maybe they weren't interested in my file, but I think it's pretty good since I got interviews at other places...