Thread:Una74/@comment-172.14.149.213-20151026163121/@comment-1597835-20151026231307

Unless someone is specifically named, we try to avoid redacting. I don't particularly want to get into the business of policing more ambiguous posts. I really only intervene if it's a clear and maliicious violation, which this does not seem to be (it was after all posted by a SC member). I think you're right that other search committees do not scour these boards for clues about candidates.

If it bothers you nonetheless, please feel free to delete it yourself; I would not revert the deletion (an explanatory note about the reason for deleting would be welcome though). Hope this helps.