Forum:Disclosing names

Hi all.

I'm Commie4Life, admin for Communication and Media Studies.

We've had a bit of a debate about disclusing names. 2 examples:

1. JOB X

Comment: "That's an inside hire of VAP Sarah Smith!"

2. JOB Y

Comment: Steve Miller got this offer and is still deciding. Yay Steve!

In the first, it is speculative.

In the second, this may be a friend/classmate of Steve Miller and Steve Miller may not be happy about the name post.

What are other discipline wikis' policies on this?

Commie4life 16:06, January 22, 2012 (UTC)